I guess I chanced upon this forum about 10 years too late! It seems like you had a special community, and it would have been fun to be part of it.
It is a pity that many of the authors are just listed as "guest" (Guest_Rose_of_Jericho, for instance) since I would really like to write compliments to some of them on their stories.
Regarding PoE...well, I found the game so insanely boring that I was hoping fanfiction might be an improvement on it! (I could probably cough up a parody, but it wouldn't be very nice and would involve characters giving massive, largely unintelligible speeches about inscrutable things, followed by some profane and lascivious language.) No offense intended to people who actually liked it - to each their own!
NWN, despite being clunky, seems to have inspired some good stories, particularly by those who took it as an open world to play in rather than going by the plot.
Will check out In the Cards